U2 GREEN DAY STRUMMERVILLE SPRINGSTEEN
What does it profit a man’s soul to engage in a charity record ? Not much if The U2/Green Day Saints Are Coming hook up and Strummerville (various Indie types including LIbs Reunited Mystery Jets Guillemots etc) version of Janie Jones is anything to go by. But if its a good cause people tend to hold their nose and put in the ear plugs and smile sweetly. Remember the dreadful DO They Know Its Christmas remake? People saying it wasn’t a patch on the original. Yeah, like the original was on anyone’s top tunes list. Far more soul enriching to do like Bruce Springsteen . Keep the best track on your (repackaged album) until the day before you play the first New Orleans jazz festival after Katrina. DRop the recording - a rewritten version of How Can A Poor Man Stand Such Times And Live - free on the internet the day before the show. And, Christ, what a show. Tears all around and that song as reconfigured by Bruce - its the sound of a fightback, of spitting in the face of the shameful elite who use New Orleans as a playground, but leave its people to die and fester when they need help. I doubt I’ll see a more impassioned and moving show than Springsteen’s at Jazz Fest for a looooong time. It had depth and meaning, it strengthened the soul. That is something better than charity So a question - the greatest charity record of all time? Any suggestions?